Guerilla Girls: The
Full Interview | From their book Confessions of the Guerilla
Girls
edited by Jasmine Trabelsi
The Guerilla girls launched their radical attack against inequality
in the art world at the 1985 Whitney Annual, protesting its exclusion
of female artists and artists of color. Their fight continues, through
tactics of public speaking (wearing gorilla maks and using names
of female artists as aliases to preserve anonymity), posters, internet
activism, and other methods of information. Their vigilance has
proved to be a real threat to sexism, racism, and general injustice
in highbrow culture. Think these problems aren't real or are just
going to go away? The Guerrilla girls will open your eyes.
Rosalba Carriera: When we first spoke to the press, it was clear
we needed code names to distinguish between members of the group.
The day we taped NPR's Fresh Air, Georgia O'Keeffe died. It was
then that it came to us to use names of dead women artists and writers
to reinforce their presence in history and to solve our interview
problems. It was as though Georgia was speaking to us from the grave.
So far, Frida Kahlo, Alma Thomas, Rosalba Carriera, Lee Krasner,
Eva Hesse, Emily Carr, Paula Modersohn-Becker, Romaine Brooks, Alice
Neel and Ana Mendieta are but a few of the famous women from history
who have joined us. We are actively recruiting Rosa Bonheur, Angelica
Kauffmann and Sofonisba Anguisolla. (Of course, one Girl didn't
care for the idea and calls herself GG1.)
How did the Guerrilla Girls start?
Kathe Kollwitz: In 1985, The Museum of Modern Art in New York opened
an exhibition titled "An International Survey of Painting and
Sculpture." It was supposed to be an up-to-the minute summary
of the most significant contemporary art in the world. Out of 169
artists, only 13 were women. All the artists were white, either
from Europe or the US. That was bad enough, but the curator, Kynaston
McShine, said any artist who wasn't in the show should rethink "his"
career. And that really annoyed a lot of artists because obviously
the guy was completely prejudiced. Women demonstrated in front of
the museum with the usual placards and picket line. Some of us who
attended were irritated that we didn't make any impression on passersby.
Meta Fuller: We began to ask ourselves some questions. Why did
women and artists of color do better in the 1970's than in the 80's?
Was there a backlash in the art world? Who was responsible? What
could be done about it?
What did you do?
Frida Kahlo: We decided to find out how bad it was. After about
5 minutes of research we found that it was worse than we thought:
the most influential galleries and museums exhibited almost no women
artists. When we showed the figures around, some said it was an
issue of quality, not prejudice. Others admitted there was discrimination,
but considered the situation hopeless. Everyone in positions of
power curators, critics, collectors, the artists themselves passed
the buck. The artists blamed the dealers, the dealers blamed the
collectors, the collectors blamed the critics, and so on. We decided
to embarrass each group by showing their records in public. Those
were the first posters we put up in the streets of SoHo in New York
.
Why are you anonymous?
GG1: The art world is a very small place. Of course, we were afraid
that if we blew the whistle on some of its most powerful people,
we could kiss off our art careers. But mainly, we wanted the focus
to be on the issues, not on our personalities or our own work.
Lee Krasner: We joined a long tradition of (mostly male) masked
avengers like Robin Hood, Batman, The Lone Ranger, and Wonder Woman.
Why do you call yourselves 'girls?' Doesn't that
upset a lot of feminists?
Gertrude Stein: Yeah. We wanted to be shocking. We wanted people
to be upset.
Frida Kahlo: Calling a grown woman a girl can imply she's not complete,
mature, or grown-up. But we decided to reclaim the word "girl",
so it couldn't be used against us. Gay activists did the same thing
with the epithet "queer."
Why are you Guerrillas?
Georgia O'Keeffe: We wanted to play with the fear of guerrilla
warfare, to make people afraid of who we might be and where we would
strike next. Besides, 'guerrilla' sounds so good with 'girl.'
Isn't calling yourselves the Conscience of the Art World a little
pretentious?
Eva Hesse: Of course. Everyone knows artists are pretentious!
GG 1: Anyway, the art world needs to examine itself, to be more
self-critical. Every profession needs a conscience!
Why the gorilla masks?
Kathe Kollwitz: We were Guerrillas before we were Gorillas. From
the beginning the press wanted publicity photos. We needed a disguise.
No one remembers, for sure, how we got our fur, but one story is
that at an early meeting, an original girl, a bad speller, wrote
'Gorilla' instead of 'Guerrilla.' It was an enlightened mistake.
It gave us our "mask-ulinity."
What about the short skirts, high heels and fishnet
stockings?
Emily Carr: Wearing those clothes with a gorilla mask confounds
the stereotype of female sexiness.
Meta Fuller: Actually, we wear mostly nondescript, black clothes
like every one else in the art world. Sometimes we do wear high
heels and short skirts. And that's what people remember.
Why do you use humor? What does it do for your
message?
Paula Modersohn-Becker: Our situation as women and artists of color
in the art world was so pathetic, all we could do was make fun of
it. It felt so good to ridicule and belittle a system that excluded
us. There was also that stale idea that feminists don't have a sense
of humor.
Eva Hesse: Actually, our first posters weren't funny at all, just
smart-assed. But we found out quickly that humor gets people involved.
It's an effective weapon.
Do you allow men to join?
Frida Kahlo: We'd love to be inclusive, but it's not easy to find
men willing to work without getting paid or getting credit for it.
Kathe Kollwitz : Seriously, we have lots of male supporters and
lots of men have asked to join. We're thinking about it.
What was the response to your earliest actions?
Anais Nin: There was skepticism, shock, rage, and lots of talk.
It was the Reagan 80's and everyone was crazed to succeed, nobody
wanted to be perceived as a complainer. Hardly any artists had the
guts to attack the sacred cows. We were immediately THE topic at
dinner parties, openings, even on the street. Who were these women?
How do they dare say that? And what do their facts say about the
art world? Women artists loved us, almost everyone else hated us,
and none of them could stop talking about us.
What have you done since then?
GG1: One poster led to another, and we have done more than sixty
examining different aspects of sexism and racism in our culture
at large, not just the art world. We've received thousands of requests
for them and they've found their way all over the world. Museums
and libraries have collected entire portfolios. We've spoken to
large audiences at museums and schools on four continents, sometimes
at the invitation of institutions and individuals we have attacked.
You sound surprised by your success. What did
you expect?
Romaine Brooks: We didn't expect anything. We just wanted to have
a little fun with our adversaries and to vent a little rage. But
we also wanted to make feminism (that "f" word,) fashionable
again, with new tactics and strategies. It was really a surprise
when so many people identified with us and felt we spoke for their
collective anger. We didn't have the wildest notion that women in
Japan, Brazil, Europe and even Bali, would be interested in what
we were doing.
What have you done besides posters?
Eva Hesse: The posters are our most public communication but we've
done other things, too, like billboards, bus ads, magazine spreads,
protest actions, letter-writing campaigns. We're particularly proud
of having put up broad sheets in bathrooms of major museums.
Rosalba Carriera: We send secret letters to egregious offenders,
often honoring them with bogus awards. We gave John Russell of The
New York Times an award for "The Most Patronizing Art Review
of 1986," when he reviewed Dorothy Dehner's show and called
her "Mrs. David Smith," referring to her famous sculptor
husband. (They had been divorced for years.)
Alice Neel: "The Norman Mailer Award for Sensitivity to Issues
of Gender Equality," went to painter Frank Stella when he said
he liked the "muscular" work of "girl" artists
like Helen Frankenthaler. We shook a hairy finger at art market
superstar Brice Marden when he said in "Vanity Fair "
that he wasn't sure if it was good for him to be represented by
a female dealer.
Tina Modotti: We sent "The Apologist of the Year Award "
to a woman critic, Kim Levin, for reviewing a show of David Salle
without dealing with his misogynist imagery. (Recently, on a panel
in Berlin, she claimed to be grateful for the criticism.)
Gertrude Stein: We send Seasons Greetings to friend and foe. We
remind the latter that "We know who's been naughty or nice."
We wish the former "Peace on Earth. Goodwill toward women."
Frida Kahlo: The next time art critic Michael Kimmelman pans a
show that actually includes a fair number of women and artists of
color like his hysterical rant against the Whitney Biennial of 1993we're
going to send him a year's supply of Midol.
Have you ever been accused of discrimination yourselves?
Alma Thomas: Yes. Menopausal women felt we were making fun of them
by titling our newsletter, Hot Flashes from the Guerrilla Girls.
I guess they didn't know the Girl who named it was having them herself.
Kathe Kollwitz: One male journalist is still threatening to sue
us for charging white males a higher subscription rate to Hot Flashes
than women or artists of color. We thought it was fair, because
white men earn more. We told him to go sue hairdressers who charge
women more for a haircut.
Romaine Brooks: We also heard from a gay white male, who was angry
about having to pay the same as straight white males. So we refined
our language to read, "Straight white males with superior earning
power: $12., Everyone else: $9."
Is there anything you'd like to apologize for?
Anais Nin: Our spelling mistakes.
Any regrets?
Gertrude Stein: Not naming more names.
How many are you?
Lee Krasner: We don't have any idea. We secretly suspect that all
women are born Guerrilla Girls. It's just a question of helping
them discover it. For sure, thousands; probably, hundreds of thousands;
maybe, millions.
How do you work?
Alice Neel: Over the past 10 years, we've come to resemble a large,
crazy, but caring dysfunctional family. We argue, shout, whine,
complain, change our minds and continually threaten to quit if we
don't get our way. We work the phone lines between meetings to understand
our differing positions. We rarely vote and proceed by consensus
most of the time. Some drop out of the group, but eventually most
of us come back, after days, months and sometimes years. The Christmas
parties and reunions are terrific. We care a+/- lot about each
other, even if we don't see things the same way. Everyone has a
poster she really hates and a poster she really loves. We agree
that we can disagree. Maybe that's democracy.
GG 1: Over the years we've managed to break the stereotype of the
artist as a difficult loner, unable to work with anyone even though
some of us might be like that in our other lives.
Zora Neale Hurston: Being anonymous, operating under code names
and alter egos, has meant there are no career gains to be earned
by being a Guerrilla Girl. This makes us all equal, gives each of
us an equal voice, and no matter what our positions may be in the
"real" world.
Where do you get your information?
Violette LeDuc: We usually just count in galleries, in museums,
in the media.
Eva Hesse: One of our best sources is the magazine Art in America,
which publishes an Annual Guide, where galleries and museums proudly
announce their "discriminating" line-ups for the year.
Alice Neel: Lots of institutions provide public information that
we reinterpret. That's how we did our exhibition about the Whitney
Museum's pathetic record of not showing women and artists of color.
GG 1: For the second issue of Hot Flashes, we wrote a phony letter
from an imaginary graduate student asking PR departments of 150
museums what was happening.
Romaine Brooks: For the first issue, we sat for days in the New
York Public Library, reading everything The New York Times wrote
about art during 1991-2. Then, we got personal dirt on the critics
from confidential sources all over town.
Ana Mendieta: We're a large, powerful anonymous group and that
means that we could be anyone, anywhere like Leo Castelli's proctologist,
Mary Boone's plastic surgeon, David Salle's hairstylist, or Carl
Andre's next girlfriend.
How often do you meet?
Tina Modotti: Every 28 days.
Who finances you?
Georgia O'Keeffe: In the beginning, we paid for the posters out
of our own pocketbooks. And we received unsolicited contributions
like one from a secretary at a NYC museum who wrote, "I work
for a curator you named on one of your posters. You're right, he's
an asshole. Here's $25." Now, we get a lot of contributions
from women artists when their careers take off. We even got a government
grant for our newsletter "Hot Flashes," to "monitor
sexism and racism in the art world." There is no one funding
source, no matron of the arts who writes us big checks, no PAC for
the Guerrilla Girls. We do accept retributions from institutions
we have attacked when they buy our posters and pay our lecture fees.
What's the ethnic make-up of the Girls?
Gertrude Stein: Our membership is a secret, but the percentage
of women of color is better than the general population.
Has anyone said your masks are racist, that they
conjure up images of lower forms of jungle life that have been used
to humiliate black people?
Zora Neale Hurston: We've talked about that. We are exploding stereotypes
here, like when we use the word "Girl."
Meta Fuller: There is nothing second-rate or inferior about gorillas
and to think so is Homo-Sapiens-centric.
Alma Thomas: I would have preferred pink ski masks.
You've also done posters about abortion rights,
the Gulf War, the homeless, rape, Clarence Thomas and other issues
that have nothing to do with the art world. Why?
Paula Modersohn-Becker: We consider ourselves inhabitants of many
worlds and can appear in any one we wish.
Liubov Popova: We wanted to try out what we had learned about making
effective posters in a larger arena.
Kathe Kollwitz: We're not systematic in our attacks. It happens
in a much less orchestrated way. Members bring issues and ideas
to the group and we try to shape them into effective posters. Sometimes
we're all interested in an issue and we can't figure out or agree
on how to make it into a poster, so we table it for a later meeting.
Emily Carr: Lots of issues are important to us. We focus on the
world for awhile, go back to the art world and come back out again.
Ana Mendieta: An event like the Gulf War, which outraged us, can
precipitate a whole bunch of posters in a very short time.
How does an artist "make it"?
Romaine Brooks: Even without discrimination, it is very hard to
succeed as an artist.
Alma Thomas: You work in your studio, then take your art around
to galleries, which act as agents for a small number of artists
and sell their art. Sometimes galleries are approached by hundreds
of hopeful artists a week. You also try to get museum curators interested
in your work. Museums are public, not-for-profit institutions that
buy and exhibit art. They are influenced by what the galleries show
and visa versa. Museums exhibit even fewer artists than galleries.
Critics fuel the process by judging your work. It is a challenge
to get their attention, because there are many more shows than reviews.
Art collectors buy from galleries and also sit on the boards and
committees at museums, advising them (and being advised by them)
on what to collect. To make a living from her art, an artist has
to crack this system.
Diane Arbus: Museums and galleries tend to exhibit the same few
artists, who are overwhelmingly white and male.
But, isn't judging art an issue of quality? If
women and artists of color were really good, wouldn't they make
it on their own?
Lee Krasner: The world of High Art, the kind that gets into museums
and history books, is run by a very small group of people. Our posters
have proved over and over again that these people, no matter how
smart or good intentioned have been biased against women and artists
of color.
Romaine Brooks: Success in art is a matter of luck and timing as
well as being good or having talent. Why do white men seem to have
all the luck? It's not just a happy accident. Thus far, and throughout
history, the system has been set up to support and promote the work
of white male artists. That is their luck. In the old days of Western
culture, it was patronage and the atelier system. It's not that
different now, though patronage doesn't come in the form of royal
courts and the Roman Catholic Church, but in the form of gallery
owners, collectors, critics and museums who back certain artists.
Once enough money has been invested in a certain artist, everyone
mobilizes to keep that artist's name out front and consequently
in history. The artists who make it in this way begin to define
quality.
Alma Thomas: "Quality" has always been used to keep women
and artists of color out.
Is art by women and artists of color different
from art by white men?
Alice Neel: If art is the expression of experience and everyone
admits that gender and race affect experience, then it stands to
reason that their work could be different.
Ana Mendieta: That's another thing that we're fighting for. We
think the art that's in the museums and galleries should tell the
whole story of our culture our real culture not just the white male
part.
Is the art world like the rest of society in its
treatment of women and artists of color, or is it a special case?
Rosalba Carriera: Many people believe that art is special and exempt
from conventional scrutiny. While art may be transcendent, the art
world should be subject to the same standards as anywhere else.
We think there's a civil rights issue here.
Zora Neale Hurston: Women and men of color have been denied equal
access to becoming artists in our culture for centuries. But there
have been many stunning exceptions and even they are neglected by
museums and written out of history books!
Paula Modersohn-Becker: Janson's History of Art, the most widely
used textbook, didn't mention a single woman artist until Janson
died. Then, his son revised it, including a big 19 out of 2,300.
Gertrude Stein: There's a popular misconception that the world
of High Art is ahead of mass culture but everything in our research
shows that, instead of being avant garde, it's derriere. Look at
our poster that compares the number of women in jobs traditionally
held by men to the number of women showing in major art galleries
("Bus companies are more enlightened than NYC art galleries.")
The art world is a lot more macho than the post office.
So you can't just stay in your studios, work really
hard and hope that you'll get noticed?
Meta Fuller: Of course not. Any veteran of the Civil Rights, Women's,
or Gay Rights movement knows that progress is the result of pressure,
protest and struggle.
Do you really want to rewrite art history and cancel out all the
white male artists we know and love?
Georgia O"Keeffe: Yes and no. History isn't a fixed, static
thing. It always needs adjustments and revisions. The tendency to
reduce the art of an era to a few "geniuses" and their
masterpieces is myopic. It has been a huge mistake. There are many,
many significant artists. We're not going to forget Rembrandt and
Michelangelo. We just want to move them over to make room for the
rest of us!
Hilton Kramer called you "Quota Queens." Do you really
think that all shows must be 50% women and artists of color?
Zora Neale Hurston: We've never, ever mentioned quotas. We've never
attacked an institution for not showing 50% women and artists of
color. But we have humiliated them for showing less than 10%.
Georgia O'Keeffe: To make up for what's happened so far in art
history, every show should be 99% women and artists of color, but
only for the next 400 years.
You hate the language that's used to describe
art. What's wrong with words like masterpiece, seminal and genius?
Frida Kahlo: If a masterpiece can only be made by a master and
a master is defined as "a man having control or authority,"
you can see what we're up against. Considering the history of slavery,
we suggest changing the words to massa' and massa's piece.
Lee Krasner: Seminalan adjective for "semen" is completely
overused to describe creative achievement and originality. Yuk.
Just thinking about it brings a bad taste to my mouth.
Tina Modotti: Next time anyone feels the urge to use the word seminal,
try germinal instead.
Anais Nin: The word genius is related to the Latin word for testicles.
Maybe that explains why it's so rarely used to describe a woman.
If the art world is so corrupt and disgusting,
why do you want to be part of it?
Kathe Kollwitz: We don't all want a piece of the pie. We are a
diverse group, different ages, different races, different sexual
orientations and different levels of art world success. Some of
us want to blow up SoHo, some have already had museum retrospectives.
What we do agree on unanimously is that women and artists of color
deserve a piece of the pie and shouldn't be prevented from getting
a big piece, if that's what they're after.
Violette LeDuc: People who attack us for wanting a piece of the
pie usually have most of it. They wouldn't attack a woman in another
field like a law graduate who wants to be a partner in a firm, or
a Supreme Court Judge.
What's your position on pornography?
Anais Nin: We plan to have a position on it as soon as we can agree
on what it is.
What about censorship? Should museums show obscene
and offensive art?
Rosalba Carriera: Sure, as long as some of it is made by women
and artists of color.
What about lesbian and gay issues?
Romaine Brooks: We support lesbian & gay rights and some of
us are queer.
Gertrude Stein: We've covered lesbian and gay issues in a number
of posters. For example, we called for the Far Right to undergo
psychoanalysis to determine the source of its interest in Robert
Mapplethorpe.
Violette LeDuc: We proclaimed that Clarence Thomas would extend
the same right to privacy he demanded for himself to homosexuals.
Alice Neel: We ridiculed homophobic AIDS paranoia in our explanation
of Natural Law.
Vanessa Bell: The first Hot Flashes poked fun at The New York Times'
puritanical language when covering lesbian & gay issues.
Georgia O'Keeffe: We would like to see art about lesbian sexuality
taken as seriously as art about gay male sexuality. And it's happening.
Doesn't the mask keep you from taking responsibility
for the charges you make? Isn't that cowardly?
Rosalba Carriera: Actually, what started off as a lark, as a way
of doing something constructive with our anger, has become a big
responsibility to a huge audience. We didn't ask for it but we're
trying to live up to it. None of us has ever profited from being
a Girl.
Ana Mendieta: Give us a break. Was the Lone Ranger a coward?
Has anyone ever tried to expose who you really are? Paula Modersohn-Becker:
One guy threatened us. But the thought of millions of angry, spear-carrying
feminists on his case was more than he could bear.
Liubov Popova: A number of years ago, two guys put up a poster
with their photos, claiming to be the Guerrilla Girls. Some weird
career strategy!
Have you made a difference?
Emily Carr: We've made dealers, curators, critics and collectors
accountable. And things have actually gotten better for women and
artists of color. With lots of backsliding.
Frida Kahlo: Just last year, Robert Hughes, who in the mid-80's
claimed that gender was no longer a limiting factor in the art world,
reviewed a show of American art in London for Time and said "You
don't have to be a Guerrilla Girl to know that there weren't enough
women in the show." That's progress, even though Hughes reneged
on a promise to apologize in this book for his past insensitivity.
Paula Modersohn-Becker: Mary Boone is too macho to admit we influenced
her in any way, but she never represented any women until we targeted
her.
Kathe Kollwitz: Museum curators feel compelled to suck up to us
on camera. They used to ignore us and hope we'd just go away.
Gertrude Stein: The situation was pathetic. It had to change. And
we were a part of that change.
Has success ruined you?
33.3%: Yes.
33.3%: No.
The rest: Undecided.
Where do you go from here?
All: Back to that jungle out there. Back to work.
One last thing. How can you stand wearing those
masks all day?
Emily Carr: It's hot.
Paula Modersohn-Becker: Not as hot as we make it out there.
Alma Thomas: But we look so beautiful, it's hard to complain.
|